Stay Fit vs Hevy (2026): Free Alternative Comparison

Stay Fit and Hevy both deliver modern workout logging—but Hevy caps routines and trims analytics history. Compare pricing, competitive leagues, routine sharing, and features.
Stay Fit and Hevy both offer polished, modern gym logging interfaces, but handle feature restrictions differently. Hevy’s free tier restricts lifters to ~4 saved routines, 7 custom exercises, and a 3-month analytics cutoff. Stay Fit offers unlimited routines, lifetime progress charts, a 4-week program generator, and competitive leagues with zero subscriptions and zero ads.
Hevy gained widespread popularity by taking Strong’s clean logging workflow, adding a social feed, and offering a more permissive starting tier. For lifters frustrated by Strong's rigid 3-routine cap, Hevy felt like the ideal modern upgrade.
However, as lifters advance past their first year of training, Hevy's freemium ceiling becomes restrictive: custom routines cap out around 4, custom exercise creation hits a hard limit of 7, and historical volume charts quietly trim everything older than 90 days.
Here is the direct, feature-by-feature comparison between Stay Fit and Hevy in 2026.
Feature Breakdown: Stay Fit vs Hevy
| Feature | Stay Fit | Hevy Free | Hevy PRO ($2.99–$9.99/mo) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free forever ($0) | Free (Capped) | $2.99–$9.99/mo, $74.99 lifetime |
| Saved Custom Routines | Unlimited | Capped at ~4 | Unlimited |
| Custom Exercises | Unlimited | Capped at 7 | Unlimited |
| Analytics History Window | Full Lifetime | Trimmed to ~3 Months | Full Lifetime |
| Program Generator | Included (4-Week Plans) | None (Manual only) | Included (Hevy Trainer) |
| Community / Social | Competitive Leagues & Share Codes | Public Social Feed | Public Social Feed |
| In-Workout Exercise Swap | Included (Matched Catalog) | Manual swap | Manual swap |
| Body Recomp Vault | Private Sandboxed Photos | Public Feed Photos | Public Feed Photos |
| Offline Reliability | 100% Offline-First (Delta Sync) | Partial (Feed overhead) | Partial |
| Verified Workout Rewards | Amazon & Apple Gift Cards | None | None |
| Platforms | Android | iOS, Android, Watch, Web | iOS, Android, Watch, Web |

Social Feed vs Competitive Leagues: The Philosophy Difference
The most noticeable architectural difference between the two apps is how they approach community:
Hevy’s Approach: The Social Media Feed
Hevy is modeled after Instagram or Strava. Every workout you complete generates a post in an open community feed where followers can like, leave comments, and view your uploaded media.
- The Upside: If you thrive on public social validation and enjoy following gym friends or fitness creators, Hevy’s feed is active and engaging.
- The Downside: For many solo lifters, social feeds introduce unnecessary gym distraction. Scrolling past stranger selfies during a 90-second rest interval disrupts mental focus, drains device battery, and creates pressure to perform for an audience.
Stay Fit’s Approach: Competitive Leagues & 8-Digit Share Codes
Stay Fit deliberately omits infinite-scroll social media feeds. Instead, it introduces gamified discipline:
- Tiered Competitive Leagues: Compete in weekly leaderboards (Bronze, Silver, Gold, Sapphire, Ruby, Diamond). You earn league points solely through consistency, completed sets, and adherence streaks.
- Frictionless Routine Sharing: Want to share your leg day routine with a training partner? Tap share to generate a unique 8-digit share code. Your partner enters the code in Stay Fit and instantly clones your complete routine—exercises, target reps, and rest timers—without needing a social profile.
flowchart TD
subgraph Hevy ["Hevy Social Model"]
H1[Log Workout] --> H2[Public Social Feed] --> H3[Likes, Comments, Vanity Scrolling]
end
subgraph StayFit ["Stay Fit Discipline Model"]
S1[Log Workout] --> S2[Weekly Tiered Leagues\n(Bronze -> Diamond)]
S1 --> S3[8-Digit Routine Share Code\n(Frictionless Buddy Clone)]
S1 --> S4[Verified Daily Rewards\n(Gift Cards)]
end
Where Hevy's Free Tier Hits a Wall
1. The 3-Month Analytics Trim
Progressive overload is a multi-year discipline. If you started training in January, comparing your squat tonnage in November against your baseline requires seeing your full historical curve. Hevy's free tier restricts your visual charts to roughly the preceding 90 days. Older data remains in their database, but you cannot review multi-month volume trends without upgrading to Hevy PRO. Stay Fit charts your entire historical performance curve from set one at no charge.
2. The 7 Custom Exercise Limit
Commercial gyms and boutique fitness studios feature specialized machines: pendulum squats, belt squats, Prime selectorized rows, or specialized attachment angles. Hevy locks you out after creating 7 custom movements, forcing you to delete existing exercises or subscribe to PRO. Stay Fit allows unlimited custom exercise creation with custom primary and secondary muscle targeting.
3. Automated Program Generation
Hevy has developed "Hevy Trainer," an algorithmic workout generator. However, it is reserved strictly for paid PRO subscribers. Stay Fit provides an automated 4-Week Personalized Programme Builder directly in its free tier, configuring balanced Push/Pull/Legs, Upper/Lower, or Full Body splits based on your available equipment.
Where Hevy Still Wins
Hevy is a mature cross-platform application with several genuine advantages:
- Apple Watch & Wear OS: If you want to leave your phone in your locker and track sets exclusively from a smartwatch, Hevy’s wearable integration is among the best in the industry.
- Web Dashboard: Hevy offers a browser portal for reviewing logs on a desktop monitor.
- iOS Availability: Stay Fit is currently Android-focused; iPhone users require Hevy or Strong.
The Verdict
- Choose Hevy if you train with an Apple Watch, want a web browser interface, or genuinely enjoy scrolling through social media fitness feeds between sets and do not mind paying $23.99/year to remove routine and analytics limits.
- Choose Stay Fit if you want an ad-free, high-performance Android tracker with unlimited custom routines, lifetime analytics charts, periodized 4-week program planning, and weekly competitive leagues—completely free forever.
Stay Fit delivers all of Hevy PRO's core power features—unlimited routines, unlimited custom exercises, lifetime analytics, and supersets—while replacing distracting social feeds with focused competitive leagues and real workout rewards.
Frequently asked questions
Is Stay Fit cheaper than Hevy?+
Stay Fit is 100% free with no subscription tiers or in-app paywalls. Hevy offers a limited free tier, but charges $2.99–$9.99/month, $23.99/year, or $74.99 lifetime for Hevy PRO to unlock more than ~4 routines and restore full analytics.
What are Hevy's free tier limits in 2026?+
Hevy's free plan permanently caps users at approximately 4 saved custom routines, 7 custom exercises, and trims analytics charts to roughly 3 months of history. Hevy Trainer (automated programming) is also locked behind the PRO paywall.
Does Stay Fit have community or social features like Hevy?+
Stay Fit takes a focused, distraction-free approach: instead of an Instagram-style social feed with influencers and comments, Stay Fit offers Duolingo-style weekly competitive leagues (Bronze to Diamond) and frictionless 8-digit routine sharing.
Can I track supersets and drop sets in both apps?+
Yes. Both apps provide grouped superset execution and drop-set tagging. However, Stay Fit includes superset logging, auto-rest timers, and 4-week program generation completely free, while Hevy places several advanced tools behind PRO.
Reader reviews
- A
Fair comparison, not a fan letter. Hevy still has a couple of nice touches, but the free plan felt like a demo for the paid one. Stay Fit matches the actual gym work and stays free. That is why it won.
- U
Used both in the same gym session. Hevy interrupted rest with upgrade noise - seven custom exercises is a joke after a year of lifting. Stay Fit's rest timer just counted down. I uninstalled Hevy in the parking lot.
- S
Dual-app test on the same program. Hevy is where analytics history gets trimmed unless you pay PRO. Stay Fit finished the workout, saved the session, and never asked for a card. That is the whole review.
- T
I still have Hevy installed so I can be honest. Opening it reminds me the social feed is noise I never asked for. Opening Stay Fit reminds me I can just train. Stay Fit is the daily driver now.
- W
Coaching two friends through this. I had them log in Hevy and Stay Fit. They both hit the same wall: PRO pricing showed up the week I actually needed charts. Stay Fit did not have a wall. We all stayed on Stay Fit.
- R
I ran Hevy and Stay Fit side by side for three weeks so this was not theoretical. Hevy still does this: the free tier still caps custom routines. Stay Fit logged the same sets, reps, and weight without a subscription. I kept Stay Fit. One star off because I still want a bigger exercise demo library.
- Z
I wanted to like Hevy. I used it for months. Then I had to make an account before I could even log a set, and I was done paying for a notebook. Stay Fit is the free logger I should have started on.
Add a comment
You might also like
View all articlesBest Free Workout Tracker Apps (2026): The Complete Guide
The definitive guide to genuinely free workout tracker apps in 2026. Compare routine caps, analytics paywalls, offline logging, and feature trade-offs across 8 leading gym apps.
GuideStay Fit vs Strong App (2026): Which Free Tracker Wins?
A direct comparison of Stay Fit and Strong App on routine caps, pricing, 4-week planning, superset execution, and offline data sync. Compare features head-to-head.
Free Workout Tracker
Best Free Hevy Alternative (2026): No Routine or Analytics Caps
Looking for a free alternative to Hevy? Stay Fit offers unlimited custom routines, custom exercises, and lifetime analytics history without a $2.99–9.99/mo PRO subscription.
Free Workout Tracker
